On April 30, KATSEYE officially made their comeback with the music video Gnarly. However, the release has sparked intense backlash from fans and media commentators, many of whom argue that specific scenes and styling choices are inappropriate for the group’s youngest member, 17-year-old Yoonchae.
The music video features several visual and audio elements that viewers have deemed unsuitable for a group including a minor. These include provocative choreography, suggestive camera angles, background audio layered with moaning sounds, and symbolic imagery—such as a close-up of flies mating—that some interpret as sexually charged.
In particular, Yoonchae’s styling, dance sequences, and screen presence have drawn criticism for appearing too adult for her age. Fans argue that these choices not only put her in an uncomfortable spotlight but also contribute to a troubling industry-wide trend.
Critics have pointed to HYBE, the agency behind KATSEYE, as a repeat offender. “It seems like HYBE wants a ‘cunty’ group image,” one user noted, “but they could easily achieve that without including minors.”
Similar accusations were made against LE SSERAFIM, whose debut era included choreography for FEARLESS, ANTIFRAGILE, and Smart that many deemed overly suggestive, despite featuring underage members at the time.
This growing backlash has reignited broader conversations about the ethical responsibilities of entertainment companies. Fans and cultural commentators alike are calling for more age-appropriate styling, choreography, and overall creative direction when it comes to idols who are still minors.
Previously, KATSEYE faced plagiarism accusations following the release of their Gnarly teaser. Netizens pointed out similarities in concept, styling, and visuals to BLACKPINK and aespa, sparking debates about originality in K-pop.
While Gnarly may have aimed for boldness and edge, the criticism it has provoked raises an urgent question: at what cost should that artistic vision come—especially when it risks compromising the well-being of young performers?
The post KATSEYE’s “Gnarly” Sparks Concern Over Age-Inappropriate Content Involving Minor Member appeared first on KBIZoom. KBIZoom – Breaking news about K-pop, K-drama, Anime/Manga and worldwide entertainment KBIZoom – Breaking news about K-pop, K-drama, Anime/Manga and worldwide entertainment
